Manifestos set out what governments want to do. Budgets set out whether those things can—and will—actually eventuate. There is a gap between Burnham’s brand and Healey’s budget. And it is young people who are going to bear the burden of this gap.
This budget felt not so much disappointing, but underwhelming. In the run up to the budget, what was surprising was the comparative lack of speculation about what John Healey’s first budget as Chancellor might look like, especially given that Andy Burnham’s choice of Chancellor seemed surprising, regardless of party or ideology.
There is no doubt that this Budget is a departure from those we saw under Rachel Reeves—and personally speaking, I was a fan of neither her budgets nor her brand of politics, particularly what felt like a tone-deaf and almost Scrooge-like decision in July 2024 to cut Winter Fuel Payments to pensioners. For a government elected in 2024, on the back of a rising wave of discontent with 14 years of Conservative-led austerity, to present a budget that really was not different to its Conservative predecessors struck me as both shocking, but also actually quite cruel, reminiscent of the hypocrisy and self-serving nature of the Johnson government. Yes, the costs of the pandemic were undoubtedly front of mind then, and an economically sound reason to cut spending, but there were better ways to have done it.
With this in mind, I am not suggesting this budget is cruel—it is not—but neither is it interesting. Quite the opposite, it feels boring, dull and most disappointingly, devoid of ambition. I was having a drink with a friend of mine yesterday, and we discussed the budget, and one of us came up with the analogy that it is the budgetary equivalent of a Tesco meal deal—safe, steady, but overwhelmingly bland and largely tasting like cardboard, and devoid of new sandwich fillings. People are frustrated with politics, particularly with central government—and Labour saw voters take this frustration out with a vengeance in May’s local elections. Yes, it was partially this that (eventually) drew Starmer to realise his time was up—but people do not simply want a change of personnel. They want to see that government is actually doing something. The fact of the matter is that government can only do things if it has the money to do so, and unfortunately, this budget doesn’t really provide that. I argue the closest it comes is the beginning of what seems to be an inordinately and unnecessarily slow process of devolving business rates, largely (but not exclusively) to areas with directly elected mayors. This is a good start—but the problem is obvious: it primarily benefits those who live in areas with them, and there seems to have been inadequate thought put into how this will actually work, or what sort of projects this revenue will go towards. It remains to be seen how this actually will work in practice as time goes on and as this is devolved.
Perhaps the most disappointing thing for me personally was that there was a lot of talk about ‘levelling up’ (I really do not miss that term at all) young people, but little action in the way of facilitating it. One thing which would have been incredibly easy and straightforward would have been to end differentiation in terms of minimum wage, and quite frankly, how this disparity (which as of April 2027 will be £1.94 per hour) is not a contravention of equalities legislation is something I do not understand. In terms of the motivation for maintaining this disparity, perhaps the thinking was that it would increase competition for jobs in what is already a tight jobs market. My oldest nephew, aged 20, who has just started his second year of university (in Manchester, as it happens), has struggled to find employment during both his gap year, as well as through both his first year at university and is still looking, largely to no avail. He is frustrated, as are his parents, who are fortunate enough to be able to support his university expenses. This is not the case for everyone, and for those young people who do have jobs, both students and non-students alike, an equalisation of the minimum wage would translate to not only more money in wage packets, but also some relief from the cost of living crisis (that, unlike levelling up, is a term that I think needs to be used more, because we are still in it).
Another way in which young people are bearing the burden of the gap between what is said and what is actually done is through the lack of overhaul of the student finance system. When my aforementioned oldest nephew filled out his student loans paperwork a couple of years ago, we as a family were collectively shocked when we realised that his student loan—the part that at least in theory covers accommodation, food and living expenses—would not even cover his rent in halls in full. He is incredibly fortunate that his parents were able to absorb the difference, but it was not easy. For many families, it would have been the difference between going to university and not going at all. As if this is not enough, students are graduating into a jobs market which is not only competitive, but also graduating into a lifetime of student debt. Fundamentally, it strikes me as unfair to saddle future generations with the ramifications of a lack of ambition on the part of the current one.
Daniel Mann is the founder of DTM Public Affairs Ltd











